By Edwin A. McDonald, DDS 

Case Study 1 

Early in my practice I was introduced to a periodontist in Dallas. We began a close working relationship for many years. He was a great mentor to me. His work was superb, and his patients had great experiences. He got to know our patients so well he could guide them to the best treatment decisions.  

One day we met, and he told me that he was retiring. I told him that he couldn’t do that to me! His response was that he had found the perfect person to partner and transition with. He had.  

The most important thing that happened was my mentor took the time and made the effort to communicate with me about what was happening. It made me realize that I was important and significant in all of this. The incoming periodontist, Ron, was a young version of his predecessor with the same meticulous surgical technique, superb results, and great patient experiences. In fact, in many ways he became better.  

Years later, Ron’s office is in the same location, just beautifully remodeled and updated. The hygienists remained for many years as did most patients and almost all referral sources. Ron has been extraordinarily successful. That makes me happy. He makes me a better dentist. 

In this case, the two periodontists were philosophically aligned, clinically similar, consistent in their judgement, and had great ability to build high trust relationships. Those four components created a powerful foundation to move smoothly from the past to a great future. 

Case Study 2 

Unlike the first case study, most transitions have gaps between the old and the new. In addition, often the existing practice needs an infusion of energy, a new and expanded mindset, and a more powerful vision to move toward what is possible. 

I have a friend that bought a very traditional relationship-based practice with tons of potential. He is different than his predecessor in his management style, approach to relationships, and desire to grow his practice. He has more than doubled it in just a few years. He also has had a complete turnover in the team. In this case, he needed a team that fit how he wanted to practice. He hired individuals who were prepared to embrace a new approach to practice.  

My friend needed to become a more effective leader of his team and develop a deeper understanding of how important they are to his current and future success. That meant investing more time and energy into getting to know everyone, communicating his career goals and learning about their career goals as they together cast a vision of the future …a worthy destination that honored the past as it created an abundant future. That meant leaving behind some beliefs, assumptions, and patterns of thinking as he matured and as they matured. 

“All of the stakeholders around a practice transition will embrace the change if they see the incoming dentist and new team members living the values that have kept them connected to the practice for many years, there is clear and frequent communication, there are genuine efforts at building trust, and there is an expressed understanding of what is mutually beneficial to all parties.”
–Dr. Edwin A. McDonald (LineofSightCoaching.com) 

By John C. Cranham, DDS 

Pete Dawson and I talked about this often. No matter how many years in practice, dentists never have everything figured out. The things that you are doing now are not going to be right forever.  

My advice to young dentists is to be open to new processes and new materials even if you have a predictable way of doing things now. Learning and adapting makes dentistry incredibly fun. Even in my 60’s I am always learning something new—like the digital 3D world of dentistry. I haven’t been this excited about dentistry ever. 

Starting out as a new dentist wasn’t easy for me. I wanted to be known for something in my community. I wanted to be known as the dentist who solved problems that other dentists couldn’t. The first thing I needed was courage to put myself out there and do whatever I needed to do.  

The second thing I needed was training, mentoring, and experience. I went to The Pankey Institute and Dawson Academy. I took all their courses. I took a veneer class with Bill Dickerson back in the day. I listened to Ross Nash and Larry Rosenbaum. At the turn of the millennium, I was trying to take the traditional occlusal information and blend it with the hottest cosmetic information at the time. (Those concepts were diametrically opposed back then. It was blasphemy to put them together.) I prevailed and became better at solving functional problems and improving aesthetics at the same time. Today, dentists do this all the time. 

I and all my colleagues coming up over the last 30 years have had to be open to change. We’ve had to try new things and work at mastering them. I don’t think I am doing anything today in the same way I was trained in dental school.  

My message in this blog is that it’s important to evolve as a dentist to stay enthusiastic about what you do and to provide the best care you can. It’s common for maturing dentists to let go of certain procedures and focus on what they enjoy most and develop specific expertise in niche services. It’s also common for other maturing dentists to continue enjoying general dentistry half of their time and focusing on complex cases the other half.  

Enjoy the relationships you build and take pride in improving your restorative work as you need to redo it. Patients are wowed by what you can do now and how you do it compared to how you did it years ago. They love learning about the advances in dentistry that benefit them.  

The relational part of practice will always be rewarding. Being able to choose what you do and who you do it with will always be wonderful. Passion for what you do is fueled by learning, so keep setting goals to learn something new and be open to that learning changing you. 

By John C. Cranham, DDS 

Every hour you invest in your practice is an hour invested in your future, so invest time in thinking about how you are spending your time. 

I am often asked if I have advice for young dentists starting out in practice. As I reflect on my own experience in practice and on conversations with other dentists in private practice, several thoughts emerge.  

There will be times when you are working in a chaotic, undisciplined environment because you are trying to care for as many people as you can fit into your day. You will become physically and emotionally tired. At some point, you will recognize that you can’t go on that way. You will need to create more disciplined systems for you and your team. You will need to develop your team members, so they can do more and save you time. You will need to hold yourself and them accountable.  

A young dentist must understand that when you run around and do many procedures, you could be confusing activity with productivity. When you’re working on highly thought-out treatment plans, you’re sitting down, you’re doing more well-organized dentistry on fewer patients. You’re also usually executing the dentistry better, which means fewer remakes.  

How do you position yourself to have the luxury of working on those types of cases? The advanced CE at Pankey and other top programs will move you along, but you need to be patient with yourself…and your patients. You will be bringing them along with you through the opportunities you have to educate them about their oral health, where it is headed, and what can be done. Don’t assume you will achieve your goals fast. Eventually, you will become known as the go-to dentist to solve problems and the cases will flow.  

Know your patients. Be thoughtful about moving them along. Enjoy them as you do. 

I’ve written about this before…for the first few years I felt my colleagues were surpassing me. They were doing more advanced cases and utilizing what they were learning at Pankey and Dawson. I had purchased a tiny practice filled with patients who valued dentistry when they were in pain. I aspired to do more than fill cavities. Sometimes I thought I would have to give up on my dream. But I kept talking with my patients, building relationships, raising their awareness, and eventually they began accepting treatment. I had to stay hopeful and employ the behaviors I was being mentored to employ before I could employ my advanced clinical skills.  

I learned a lot about people, not just dentistry, in my early years. I look back upon the experience with fondness now. 

By John C. Cranham, DDS  

Sometimes you can see clearly where you want to go with your dental practice. I can vividly remember driving my car to St. Petersburg for my first class taught by Pete Dawson. It was 1989. When the class was over, I drove my little car all the way back to my 800-square-foot office in Portsmouth, Virginia, and arrived at four o’clock in the morning. I had just bought the office from a doctor who did mostly silver fillings—maybe only four crowns in the entire year. I remember I could visualize what I wanted to do with “my” practice but deciding the first steps was overwhelming.  

A dental office can be the loneliest place in the world. I had to figure out the attainable steppingstones. We didn’t have the internet back then. Finding mentors and connecting with supportive, sharing colleagues was more difficult. In dentistry today, it’s easier to find those steppingstones. One of the most rewarding things I do today is helping dentists develop. 

I caution dentists to not assume they will achieve their big goals fast. There is a temptation to give up when progress is slow. You’ve got to stay on the path to get to where you want to go. Think about your goals and steppingstones every day but be kind to yourself if it takes more time than you visualized.  

Remember that everyone is different. All your buddies are going to be in different cities, different socioeconomic areas, and different practices. They’re going to have different opportunities. Social media can be your enemy when it comes to self-confidence and determination. There will be certain people that develop faster.  

I can remember being very frustrated the first year or two in my little town of Portsmouth. There were dentists going through the same classes I was and were already doing the kinds of cases that I wanted to do but wasn’t doing yet. During the first two years in practice, I sometimes wondered if I would ever do the kind of dentistry I wanted. But I kept in conversation with my patients, eventually they began accepting treatments, and the floodgates finally opened.  

One of the greatest things about this profession is we can always strive to be great. I don’t think I’m there yet. It’s the striving part—the working at it and seeing things improve that makes it so fun and rewarding. I love it.  

People ask me, why are you setting BHAGs at this stage in your life? You’ve already accomplished so much. Why are you totally reinventing your practice systems? Why are you going fully digital after practicing on analog articulators for 35 years? 

What I’ve been able to do in dentistry is constantly reinvent myself, and I feel like I am growing in what I can do. So, I say it’s because reinvention is awesome. It’s fun. And my staff knows that if I get something working well, I’m going to find a way to make it even better tomorrow. 

By John C. Cranham, DDS 

Even today, after decades into family life, dental practice, and continuing dental education, I sit down every January to outline my BHAGs (Big Hairy Audacious Goals) for the year. I block out the first Monday after Christmas to do this, but for the previous month, I’ve been thinking about what new goals will excite me most. I commonly do this type of thinking while I am exercising and driving.  

It’s during these alone times that I can intentionally mull over the things I could do next. I pay close attention to which possibilities excite me most. Oftentimes, these are goals that I feel will benefit others. 

Successful people have the ability to create daily behaviors that direct themselves towards their goals and take them forward on steppingstones. One of the simplest, yet powerful things I witnessed Dr. Pete Dawson do is how he started each day. He would go to his desk and spend 15 to 20 minutes writing six things on a 3×5 card. These weren’t a To Do list. These were six things that would direct him toward his next BHAG. He would place the card in his breast pocket. He did this day in and day out. 

Two weeks before he passed, Pete came to my lake house on oxygen. When he arrived, I had to help him out of the car and into the house on his walker. I looked at his shirt pocket, and there it was, the 3×5 card.  

We don’t have to use 3×5 cards to make notes for ourselves. We can use our phones. But it is powerful to reflect daily on steps that will take us in the direction we want to go and record those steps to lock them in our memory.  

In dentistry, we need to carve out habitual time to think about our goals and steppingstones. We need to carve out time to take the identified steps. The point is to have a system in place where you are thinking about it every day, because there is so much coming at us all day long that we are at risk of drowning in the noise.  

When we get caught up in the mundane, life is less interesting and less fulfilling. At least that has been my experience. When you sense you are becoming bored, you might just need to identify the next big goal that excites you. The challenge of getting there will bring you back to full life. 

By John C. Cranham, DDS  

Having BHAGs (Big Hairy Audacious Goals) has been important to me for my whole life, whether it was the Ironman triathalon, getting the opportunity to teach with Dr. Peter Dawson, finishing my book, or setting big goals for my practice. The biggest things in my life that were important to me from a professional standpoint started with an idea that got me excited but seemed impossible. 

A BHAG has a way of motivating you when you think there’s a sliver of chance that you might be able to do it. You set it as a goal and proactively discover steps to work towards it; then you get out of bed each day intent on moving forward.  

People are “wired” differently, but I do think extremely successful people do this. Pete Dawson was like this. He died four years ago, and I remember being with him at my lake house two weeks before he passed away. He talked about a BHAG he was working on–a new book, and he showed me the layout he had in mind for it.  

If you don’t have a BHAG (the next big goal that’s exciting to you), it’s easy to get caught up in the day-to-day routine. I can think of times in my life when dentistry became mundane. 

One of the most amazing times in my life was right after I was invited to teach with Pete Dawson. I was on the faculty before I was the clinical director. After I was teaching there, there was a six-month period when I was a little depressed. I didn’t understand the feeling. One night at dinner with Pete, I told him I was struggling. We talked about it for a few minutes, and then he said, “It sounds like you need a new goal.” 

That hit me like a ton of bricks. Once I have attained a goal, I need a new aspiration to chase.  

BHAGs are our reasons to get out of bed every morning and be fulfilled by our efforts. Even if we don’t quite complete everything we visualize, we still end up in a completely different place. And in my experience, it’s always a better one. 

By Edwin “Mac” McDonald DDS  

Change isn’t just about external circumstances; it’s also an inner evolution. We go on a transformative journey, and our reflections as we go touch upon our intention and legacy, our personal identity amidst the change, and decisions we make as the change unfolds.  

Challenge 1: Intention and Legacy 

When facing change, having a clear intention is like setting the compass for your journey. What legacy do you aspire to leave behind? Aligning your actions with your deeply held beliefs ensures congruence between your intentions and outcomes. But stress may cause you to move away from your most deeply held beliefs. I’ve witnessed this happen, just as I’ve witnessed deeply held beliefs guide what happens. 

Challenge 2: Personal Identity Amidst Change 

The question “Who do I want to be during this transition?” is profound. It invites introspection. Consider how you want to show up for yourself and those around you, especially those who are most important to you. Authenticity matters. 

Challenge 3: Listening and Accountability 

Change often involves decisions. Whose voices matter? Listening deeply to trusted individuals—those who respect and understand you—can provide valuable perspectives. Forming a leadership team of diverse viewpoints helps guide you toward success. 

The Importance of Values During Dental Practice Mergers and Acquisitions 

Many private dental practices are being acquired by large partnerships in 2024. These transitions have tons of potential and profit associated with them. Associated with these transitions are complex changes for the practice owner and team members…expanded ownership, more complex organizational structure, new operational systems, and a distancing of some decision making. They also come with the unknown of who will be your future partners after the next sale of the organization. Are you prepared for all of that?  

Preparing yourself and your team is essential. On the front end, asking every possible question including questions about the partnership’s core values, how they are integrated into the day-to-day operations, and communicating the importance of that to you and your team is essential to long term success. These questions and expressions are an attempt to examine the congruence and compatibility between you, your team, and your new partners. 

I am witnessing several friends transition successfully to one of these new partnerships. The common factor I observe is that each dentist has great self-awareness and received very strong assurance that they would retain autonomy to continue to practice according to the most deeply rooted values. I also observed that the large partnership was very stable with excellent systems and had high quality leadership.  

My father often told me: “The person that you have an agreement with is more important than the agreement itself.” In other words, a person of strong character will find a way to honor the intent of the agreement regardless of the specific circumstances of the moment. Values have longevity. Circumstances come and go. 

I have also witnessed an abandonment of strongly held values as an organization was going through the painful changes of decline. In abandoning their values, stakeholders were hurt and distanced themselves. It intensified and accelerated the decline. Values matter. Character counts. Clinging to our core values in times of change or decline will increase and accelerate recovery. There are countless Fortune 500 case studies to support this idea. 

Another Example of Values in Transition from My Life 

Finally, I want to leave you with a case study from my church, The Village Church. We had become a multi-site church in response to the demand of many people attending our main campus. As it grew, our leadership became painfully aware that it was not fulfilling our mission and it was not consistent with our closely held values of community and individual relationships. Over a period of several years, each church was given the opportunity to vote on becoming independent. They all voted around 95% in favor of the change. We gave away around 40 million dollars of real estate, equipment, furniture, and other assets to all of the churches.  

Today, the new independent churches are thriving as is our main campus where we attend. The decision was in conflict with everything that is happening in our business and church worlds where there is constant consolidation and scaling. However, the decision was consistent with the values that drive the purpose of the church. The change created multiple thriving churches that are serving their specific communities and growing people and their impact on our world. 

By Mary Osborne, RDH 

How much time do you schedule for a new patient, non-emergency visit? Is your priority efficiency or effectiveness? Is your goal to gather as much clinical data as possible, or is it to begin to build a relationship of mutual trust? Both are possible if you see the new patient visit as more of a process than an event.   

Too often new patients are rushed through an assembly line: brief conversation, clinical exam, diagnostic records, and treatment presentation! Is that really the best way to help people make choices about their health?  

There is no one right way to schedule a new patient. Different practices are successful with different models based on the values of the practice, practice growth, and the personality and skills of doctors and team members. The most important determinant of success is our ability to meet each patient where they are and join them on a journey to health. I am not suggesting we should be without practice standards of care.  We have a responsibility to decide what we need before beginning treatment. Our challenge is to guide patients to understanding why we need what we need, and why that is relevant to their unique situation.   

We may anticipate that patients will resist this type of experience, but if we make it truly about the patient and are flexible, I have found that patients are more than willing to participate in an individualized process that best meets their temperament and circumstances. 

I remember seeing a new patient that I was told was a “very busy attorney” because his secretary said so when she made the appointment and his wife said so when she confirmed the appointment. I anticipated that he would be a driver and prepared to efficiently move him through his appointment.  

As I explored his health history with him he expanded on the specific answers to questions. Soon, he was leading the conversation. When I remarked that I wanted to make sure we were making good use of his time. He said, “Mary, what’s this about time?” I replied that I knew he was very busy. He said, “Mary, this is about me. I have time for me.” 

His statement has stayed with me because I realized that if the conversation had been about me going through my check list and not listening to him, it would not have been a worthwhile experience for him. It also wouldn’t have been a worthwhile experience for me. 

I have learned that when the patient feels in control of the process they are willing to give that time to themselves. A lot of aha moments occur as they learn about themselves while speaking. When patients feel like they are on an assembly line being moved through our system, they have every right to be resistant.  

Empowering patients to lead the process is both an attitude and a learnable skill. When we can lose ourselves in the moment, really listen, really encourage, and really care about the patient’s thoughts and feelings, it is easy to make connections to the next step we recommend.  It is my experience that I can more quickly become a trusted health advisor when I intentionally share control with my patient. 

Most patients are willing to invest more time in the process when they see the connection between their needs and what we recommend.  These are typically patients who have or have had complex health issues and are seeking to improve and retain health. They perceive the value of the extended process and how much value you place on spending in-depth time with them.  

The entire team’s communication can deliver the message that everyone in the practice is keenly interested in them, and their appointment is uniquely planned to meet their needs.  

What has been your experience? Are you open to scheduling more time for conversations that typically garner trust and appreciation earlier in the relationship? 

Laura S. Harkin, DMD 

I’m the owner of a third-generation dental practice. My father was a special person who cared for his patients as much as he did his dentistry. One important piece of advice that he gave was to make sure that my patient records were always complete and pristine. He said, “Anything that you are sending to the laboratory or to a specialist, even down to how you write your lab script or note, must be precise. And the reason is not only to minimize adjustment at the end but to also set an expectation for the same level of care returned by the lab or specialist.” 

As a team, we have spent time evaluating our models and photos to discuss how they can be improved and to recognize our highest standard. Recently, I became a little concerned about some of the radiographs we’d taken in the office. I encountered a few bitewings in which I was able to see the bone levels or the image wasn’t anterior enough to check the distal of the canine. So, as a team, we set aside time to review current x-rays and discuss the diagnostic qualities that we seek to achieve in each type.  

A team huddle provides built-in time and a safe place to do something like this. While reviewing the images, it became very clear that the team knew how to take vertical and horizontal bitewings. They also had a clear visual for how the images should look. Sometimes, however, a team member was shy about retaking an x-ray for they worried that a patient would be uncomfortable with the process. Other times, I imagine, they felt pressed for time and hurried to move down their checklist. 

Our review of images reinforced the level of care we collectively aim to achieve in all facets of our clinical day. Just as we strive for beautiful, mounted study casts, we take our x-rays with intention for our ourselves, our referral sources, and, above all, our patients. Consider taking a team meeting to share each other’s tips and tricks for taking x-rays in patients with difficult anatomy, a gag reflex, or missing teeth. Our own team members have a wealth of knowledge that sometimes doesn’t move from one treatment room to the next! 

By Pina Johnson, Professional Certified Coach, and Edwin (Mac) McDonald, DDS 

B.F. Skinner, a noted 20th century behavioral psychologist, conducted an intriguing and provocative experiment using laboratory mice. Using behavioral conditioning he was able to condition one group of mice to believe that through their actions they were able to determine their fate. Using the same methodology, he also succeeded in conditioning another group of mice to believe that there was nothing they could do to alter their fate. 

He then placed the first group of mice, the ones that believed their actions mattered, into a large tub filled with water. As anticipated, this group of mice, when placed in a life-threatening situation, acted instinctively and began to swim to the side of the large water-filled tub. Upon reaching the edge of the tub the mice were able to crawl out to safety. 

The second group of mice, the ones that believed that their actions were meaningless, when placed in the tub of water, simply sank to the bottom and drowned. Appropriately, the lack of responsiveness displayed by the second group of mice was termed “learned helplessness.” 

Culture Lifts or Sinks Ambition 

Belief that our actions and choices matter is essential to “making things happen.” 

According to Edgar Schein, an icon of modern leadership thought, the primary function of leadership is to create an organizational culture. The culture that we choose to create will influence every aspect of our organization and ultimately determine our dental practice’s success or failure. 

Value-based leaders understand the power to alter the course of the organization does not reside with a few; it is shared by many. Organizations with cultures based on shared beliefs and purpose are higher performing. Leaders of the highest performing organizations foster cultures rich in collaborative decision making and a profound belief that everyone has influence. 

Counter Learned Helplessness by Empowering Self-Confidence 

We have come to recognize that good-old “self-confidence” is a learned competency, and effective leaders create organizational cultures that promote and teach self-confidence to each individual team member. This is accomplished by empowering teams through collaborative decision making and ensuring each team member has been given the knowledge, skill, support, resources, and appropriate authority to accomplish each task required to meet the shared goal. 

Unleash Teamwork and Creativity 

In organizations with shared leadership cultures, human self-confidence is unleashed beyond saving oneself to act in the best interest of the organization. Knowing that our individual actions will have some effect on our organization’s future (and thus on our own future and the future of others we value) compels us to want to take actions that have positive benefit for everyone. This is “meaningful” for the individuals within the organization. This raises their engagement in the work and simultaneously generates a sense of wellbeing.  

In our dental practices, “We are serving others with empathy and care to ultimately improve their wellbeing.” This is a form of love. It begets appreciation and reciprocity. When the slings and arrows of daily life initiate negative thoughts of being out of control of a situation, remembering our purpose and prior successes enables us to see disappointments and frustrations as opportunities to create a new type of approach and carry on. 

The goal for effective leaders is to allow all of this to happen in a psychologically safe environment in which our staff need not fear repercussions for their well-intended actions even if the outcome of these actions is less than ideal. By creating organizational cultures that are psychologically safe, we draw out our organizational creativity which is often stifled by the psychological repression found in command-and-control cultures. 

Creative thinking is considered to be one our highest-level cognitive functions and has been found to be a distinguishing characteristic of exceptional organizations. The wise leader understands that their organization is best served through shared power, collaboration, and utilization of their organization’s collective creativity.